Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joe Panzica's avatar

i don’t trust the characters or the plots of stories. i just don’t trust stories at all. That doesn’t mean i can avoid struggling with them. And it doesn’t mean i believe that i or anyone else can avoid weaving or absorbing them.

Stories are a large component of what is creating us to be human, and a major portion of what we are driven create. They must always be “handled with care,” for we are never the stories we tell ourselves we are any more than we are the stories others tell about us — or that anyone tries to tell us that we are.

Of course, even the statement, “We are not the stories we tell ourselves we are” could be a story — or the germ of one. And the distrust of stories is not original to me anymore than it probably was to Plato who told wonderfully sneaky stories himself

I appreciate the intention to emphasize character over plot. Plots, by necessity, have some kind of arc. The multidimensional realities that exist outside of our stories, but which much weave through them, have too many arcs to have any one be meaningfully attributed to it all. Characters can be given a single “arc” but only in stories that might be bad, that might be good. I do not trust stories.

Persons have many arcs. I’d wager it’s impossible for any of us not to experience all kinds of ups and downs (ins and outs, expansions and contractions) in any particular moment whether that moment lasts less than a second, across decades, or for some luminaries, across centuries and millennia. We can only be cognizant of very few of these at a time. And we can hold onto and examine them almost exclusively with only language, imagery, and symbolic patterns based on subliminal notions of space and time. Yet, long before the quizzical revelations of quantum physics, persons have always had inklings of creative forces that exist outside of space and time. And of course we tell stories about them. I do not trust stories even though I admire some just as I admire certain crafted images and strands of music. Admiration is not trust. Admiration or fear is not faith.

In life, as in crafting (or experiencing) stories we can experience joy, vertigo, or calm transcendence if we find ourselves surfing from crest to crest — or even persevering through troughs that may accelerate, may provide friction, may seem to paralyze, and may suddenly open to new possibilities. Or we may experience despondency, futility, shame, or rage. Sometimes we can choose. (But that’s ANOTHER set of stories…)

Mark Reda's avatar

This is very helpful information for someone like me that is new to writing. Currently my writing is more about people and trends in general, and not focusing on specific characters. But if I get inspired to write that type of writing, then this will be helpful. I can't believe you actually have a painting of your character. I would never be able to get the eyes correct. For the new novel, were you able to apply your mediumship to see what these people were really like? Inquiring minds want to know.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?